C
ClearView News

Which are the best mince pies?

Author

James Holden

Published Mar 07, 2026

Which are the best mince pies?

Stock up on the very best mince pies this Christmas
  • WINNER: Baking Agent Mini MincePies.
  • RUNNER-UP: Costa Coffee All Butter MincePies.
  • Morrisons The Best All Butter MincePies.
  • Aldi Specially Selected MincePies.
  • M&S Collection MincePies.
  • Asda Extra Special Luxury MincePies.

Herein, which supermarket does the best mince pies?

This year's best mince pies are from Marks & Spencer, according to baking experts at Which?, with Iceland the much cheaper runner-up. The panel blind-tested 11 supermarket premium mince pies to uncover the most delicious, as well as the blandest, wettest and least appetising.

Beside above, what do you have with mince pies? 'Ideally, mince pies for a drinks party will be served gently warmed, but if eating at home you could serve them much warmer with gently melting ice cream, rum or brandy butter.

Likewise, how much are Marks and Spencer mince pies?

M&S collection mince pies have been crowned the best on offer from supermarkets this Christmas. Costing 38p a pie, or £2.25 per pack, the pastries scored 87% in a blind taste test of 11 premium pies organised by Which?, the consumer affairs charity.

How do you make Mary Berry mince pies?

Ingredients

  1. 175g/6oz plain flour.
  2. 75g/2½oz cold butter, cubed.
  3. 25g/1oz icing sugar, plus extra for dusting.
  4. 1 large orange, grated zest only.
  5. 1 free-range egg, beaten.

What does mince pie taste like?

The flavor of real mincemeat pie (not the bottled version purchased at your local store) is sort of like a Middle Eastern mixture of cloves, cinnamon and nutmeg. There's a definite meaty taste, which I really liked, with an ever-so-slight sweet flavor.

Which supermarket mince pies are vegan?

Top 5 Vegan Mince Pies
  1. Greggs. Price: £1.75 for 6 pies. Pastry: 4/5. Filling: 3/5.
  2. Café Nero. Price: £2 for 1 pie. Pastry: 4/5. Filling: 4/5.
  3. Sainsbury's. Price: £1.50 for 4 pies. Pastry: 4/5. Filling: 3/5. Aesthetics: 3/5.
  4. Lidl. Price: £1.79 for 4. Pastry: 3/5. Filling: 3/5. Aesthetics: 3/5.
  5. Co-op. Price: £1 for 4 pies. Pastry: 2/5. Filling: 2/5. Aesthetics: 1/5.

Can you freeze shop bought mince pies?

As they are home-made they do not keep quite as long as commercial mince pies and we suggest that you keep them in an airtight container for up to one week. The baked mince pies do freeze very well and can be frozen for up to 3 months.

Why do people have mince pies at Christmas?

Mince Pies, like Christmas Puddings, were originally filled with meat, such as lamb, rather than the dried fruits and spices mix as they are today. They were also first made in an oval shape to represent the manger that Jesus slept in as a baby, with the top representing his swaddling clothes.

Which supermarket is best for fruit and veg?

Tesco and Sainsburys are about on par with decent fruit and veg, and then you have Morrisons, which I have heard good things about. Then the two more expensive stores in Marks and Spencer, and Waitrose.

Are M&S mince pies vegetarian?

These are M&S mince pies, made for everyone. Whether you opt for our classic Collection mince pie, deep-filled with vine fruit and a hint of cognac, Plant Kitchen vegan mince pies or Made Without wheat versions, they promise a true taste of Christmas.

Does mincemeat pie need to be refrigerated?

MINCEMEAT PIE — BAKED
Refrigerate within 2 hours of baking; cover pie loosely with aluminum foil or plastic wrap. To freeze, wrap pie tightly with aluminum foil or plastic freezer wrap, or place in heavy-duty freezer bag.

Are mince pies vegetarian?

The modern mince pie is generally a vegetarian product although it is always handy to check the packaging for the green veggie logo or ask for a list of ingredients.

What is the best mince pie 2019?

Stock up on the very best mince pies this Christmas
  • WINNER: Baking Agent Mini Mince Pies.
  • RUNNER-UP: Costa Coffee All Butter Mince Pies.
  • Morrisons The Best All Butter Mince Pies.
  • Aldi Specially Selected Mince Pies.
  • M&S Collection Mince Pies.
  • Asda Extra Special Luxury Mince Pies.

Do mince pies contain alcohol?

Experts say that despite the notion of a sumptuous, brandy-laden mince pie, there isn't much alcohol in the regular shop-bought pies. Alcohol helps to give the pies a 'robust' flavour, but by the time they have been cooked, there isn't much spirit left. The advice is to check the ingredients carefully when buying.

How many calories are in a Waitrose mince pie?

Each pie contains 259 calories, 10.2g fat and 18.6g sugar. Meanwhile, Waitrose Christmas Deep Filled Shortcrust Mince Pies have an identical calorie and fat content.

How much does a mince pie weigh?

Nutrition
Typical ValuesPer 100gOne Mince Pie (66g)
Fibre2.1g1.4g
Protein4.2g2.8g
Salt0.3g0.2g
* Reference intake of an average adult (8400 kJ / 2000 kcal)--

Are mince pies sold all year round?

They are actually sold year round in some stores. The NewFoodsUK Instagram page shared an image of mince pies in an Asda store - and was met with a mixed reaction.

How many mince pies are sold in the UK annually?

Britain as a whole are set to eat 781,177,935 mince pies in total this Christmas

Why are Marks and Spencer shares falling?

Marks & Spencer to drop out of FTSE 100 for first time. M&S's demotion reflects a share price at nearly a 20-year low as a long-running sales slump at the retailer's clothing arm is compounded by the high street crisis affecting rivals including Debenhams and House of Fraser.

Where was the first M&S store?

In 1904 Marks & Spencer opened their first shop in a covered arcade in Leeds. In the 1920s we adopted the revolutionary policy of buying directly from suppliers. In 1926 Marks and Spencer Limited became a public company.

What temperature do you reheat mince pies?

To thaw the pies remove them from the boxes and put them on a wire rack at room temperature for about 1 hour. The pies can be reheated in a low oven (120c/250F) for 3-4 minutes.

What cream do you have with mince pies?

Mince pies are quite acceptably served with all sorts of toppings. Some favourites include rum butter, vanilla ice cream, custard, and rum or brandy butter. It is also not uncommon for customers to enjoy their mince pies with single cream, double cream, whipped cream, or Greek yoghurt.

How long do you heat a mince pie for?

Counterintuitive as it may seem, microwaving a mince pie for between ten and 15 seconds, and then letting it stand for two minutes or so, does the job well and conveniently. The microwaves heat the mincemeat very quickly, but the pastry case is hardly affected.

What should I serve with pie?

More videos on YouTube
  • ROASTED PARMESAN BROCCOLI.
  • AUTUMN CHOPPED SALAD WITH CREAMY POPPYSEED DRESSING.
  • HASSELBACK SWEET POTATOES WITH GARLIC HERB BUTTER.
  • GERMAN POTATO SALAD.
  • INSTANT POT CAULIFLOWER MAC AND CHEESE.
  • EASY BRUSSELS SPROUTS AND BACON.
  • BALSAMIC ROASTED VEGETABLE AND QUINOA SALAD.

Are mince pies good for you?

Mince pies. Mince pies are typically a simple combo of pastry (flour and fat) and a spoonful of mincemeat (dried fruit with suet, sugar and spices). Pastry usually makes up more than half the ingredients in a mince pie, so it tends to be higher in fat but lower in sugar and nutrients than a slice of Christmas cake.

How do you reheat a pie in the microwave?

An already cooked pie reheat guide
Wrap the whole thing in a paper towel to keep the moisture in; Turn the oven to 200 C; Microwave the pie for 2 to 3 minutes depending on your microwave's power; Put the pie in the stove and cook for another 3 minutes to end up with a crunchy crust.

How many mince pies can you eat in a minute?

The World Record of 'most mince pies eaten in one minute' has been achieved by Mr. David Theroux from Lira, Uganda. On December 26, 2015; During Christmas event, Mr. Theroux ate Three (3) mince pies in one minute.

How do you eat pie?

Use the fork only if the pie is served without ice cream. Use both the fork and spoon if the pie is served ala mode (topped with ice cream). Place the fork in your left hand, tines down to secure the pie on the plate. Then with the spoon in the right hand, eat both the pie and ice cream.

Can you use self raising flour instead of plain for pastry?

The base of my pastry case has risen during baking.
This can happen if self raising flour is used – only plain flour should be used when making pastry. You also need to carefully press the pastry into the tin, making sure that no air is trapped underneath.

How do you reheat mince pies in the oven?

If reheating cooked mince pies that have been recently made or left to defrost, put them on an oven tray and give them about 6 -7 minutes at 180C in a conventional oven or give them a few minuets more if you heat them from frozen.

How do you make mince pies out of tin?

Another way to stop the mince pies from sticking to the tin is by rubbing sunflower oil on a greaseproof or baking paper. You can fold it in the tin. Even though it will stick with pie but you can tear it off once you are done with cooking. At least this paper will prevent the mince pie from sticking to the tin.

How do you freeze mince pies?

Get ahead: Freeze uncooked pies in their tins for up to three months, wrapped in clingfilm. Bake from frozen as in step 4, allowing 5min extra. Or, pack cooked pies (without icing sugar) into freezerproof boxes. Freeze for up to three months.

Is there meat in a mince pie?

Mincemeat, the traditional filling for mince pies, is a spicy preserve comprising a mixture of dried fruit, apple, suet and candied fruit and spices steeped in rum or brandy. It has been part of British cookery for centuries and did originally contain meat, though now the only meat present is in the suet.